Andrew Karr
Casey Wagner
1.) We thought the findings would be about the same still today as they were in the first study. Not much has changed when it comes to broadcasting and covering women's sports when compared to men's sporting events.
2.) In order to gain more media coverage, women's sports may need to show even more sex appeal. Granted this will probably never happen, but it's an ugly truth. Also, possibly a woman's sports networking focusing directly on covering women's sports. Even an hour long show each day highlighting women's sports would be a sufficient steps forward in covering those sporting events.
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Elizabeth Lambert
This is a story that has caught a lot of national attention recently. Elizabeth Lambert is a soccer player for the University of New Mexico who has caught a lot of criticism from her actions on the field in a game against Brigham Young University. She has since been suspended from the team for a year.
Just recently she responded to the criticism and the suspension on November 17th in a New York Times article by Jere Longman saying,
"I still deeply regret it and will always regret it. I think the way the video came out, it did make me look like a monster. I definitely feel because I am a female it did bring about a lot more attention than if a male were to do it. It's more expected for men to go out there and be rough. The female, we're still looked at as, Oh, we kick the ball around and score a goal. But it's not. We train very hard to reach the highest level we can get to. The physical aspect has maybe increased over the years. I'm not saying it's for the bad or it's been too overly aggressive. It's a game. Sports are physical."
I think her response directly correlates with what we have been discussing in class. That is that women may be held to a higher standard in sports and that there are expectations for women athletes to behave in a certain way on and off the field of play. She brings up good points in her response about how women aren't as expected to be as rough on the field as men are. While this may be true and they are held to a different standard I think what she did went far beyond what is acceptable of any athlete. The way she acted on the field is inexcusable and would not be seen as justified even if she were a male athlete. What she did was almost barbaric. If a male soccer player was to do the same things she did it would garner just as much criticism as she received. He would have received just as harsh of a punishment and it would gain a lot of attention from the media. It is true that sports are physical, but sports are not intended to be violent. She should be glad that no assault charges have been brought against her.
I think that Lambert has a point that women may be held to a higher standard on and off the playing field. But no matter who you are at what level this kind of behavior is not necessary nor is it justifiable.
Just recently she responded to the criticism and the suspension on November 17th in a New York Times article by Jere Longman saying,
"I still deeply regret it and will always regret it. I think the way the video came out, it did make me look like a monster. I definitely feel because I am a female it did bring about a lot more attention than if a male were to do it. It's more expected for men to go out there and be rough. The female, we're still looked at as, Oh, we kick the ball around and score a goal. But it's not. We train very hard to reach the highest level we can get to. The physical aspect has maybe increased over the years. I'm not saying it's for the bad or it's been too overly aggressive. It's a game. Sports are physical."
I think her response directly correlates with what we have been discussing in class. That is that women may be held to a higher standard in sports and that there are expectations for women athletes to behave in a certain way on and off the field of play. She brings up good points in her response about how women aren't as expected to be as rough on the field as men are. While this may be true and they are held to a different standard I think what she did went far beyond what is acceptable of any athlete. The way she acted on the field is inexcusable and would not be seen as justified even if she were a male athlete. What she did was almost barbaric. If a male soccer player was to do the same things she did it would garner just as much criticism as she received. He would have received just as harsh of a punishment and it would gain a lot of attention from the media. It is true that sports are physical, but sports are not intended to be violent. She should be glad that no assault charges have been brought against her.
I think that Lambert has a point that women may be held to a higher standard on and off the playing field. But no matter who you are at what level this kind of behavior is not necessary nor is it justifiable.
Those Soccer Plays, in Context
Disbilities and sport: Lincoln West Wrestlers
For this entry I decided to focus on athletes with disabilities. In particular I chose a couple high school wrestlers from Lincoln-West High School in Cleveland, Ohio who each has disabilities of their own but were able to overcome them and be successful on the mat as well as becoming close friends.
When Leroy Sutton was 11 he was in a horrific accident where he was pulled beneath a train and lost both of his legs as a result. Before his senior year of high school he transferred to Lincoln-West where he met Dartanyon Crockett who shared some of his struggles. He was legally blind. They became very good friends and trained and wrestled together. Crockett would also carry Sutton on his back into every match.
Dartanyon, while wrestling at 189 pounds went on to win the league championship with a record of 26-3. Leroy didn't achieve as much success on the mat but was a vital part of the team and his will alone inspired other wrestlers on the team.
Stories like these are what make people realize that their everyday struggles are nothing compared to the struggles these athletes face on and off the mat. It really puts things in perspective for me as far as when I say I am having a bad day. I couldn't imagine not having legs or being legally blind. So when people say they are having a bad day it pales in comparison to what these two go through on a daily basis. For these two young men to overcome everything they have to everyday and still be successful athletes is incredible to me and inspiring. So the next time you think you are having a bad day, just think about those who are so much less fortunate than you and don't even have the basic abilities of being able to walk or see. It really puts things in perspective for me and makes me realize how fortunate I am to have those abilities and the chance to get a college education. Both of these wrestlers, while graduating high school have dreams about going to college but they just don't have the finances. So the main point to take from this post is to be grateful for everything you have everyday; because Leroy Sutton and Dartanyon Crockett are more than grateful for what they have.
Link: http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/otl/news/story?id=4371874
When Leroy Sutton was 11 he was in a horrific accident where he was pulled beneath a train and lost both of his legs as a result. Before his senior year of high school he transferred to Lincoln-West where he met Dartanyon Crockett who shared some of his struggles. He was legally blind. They became very good friends and trained and wrestled together. Crockett would also carry Sutton on his back into every match.
Dartanyon, while wrestling at 189 pounds went on to win the league championship with a record of 26-3. Leroy didn't achieve as much success on the mat but was a vital part of the team and his will alone inspired other wrestlers on the team.
Stories like these are what make people realize that their everyday struggles are nothing compared to the struggles these athletes face on and off the mat. It really puts things in perspective for me as far as when I say I am having a bad day. I couldn't imagine not having legs or being legally blind. So when people say they are having a bad day it pales in comparison to what these two go through on a daily basis. For these two young men to overcome everything they have to everyday and still be successful athletes is incredible to me and inspiring. So the next time you think you are having a bad day, just think about those who are so much less fortunate than you and don't even have the basic abilities of being able to walk or see. It really puts things in perspective for me and makes me realize how fortunate I am to have those abilities and the chance to get a college education. Both of these wrestlers, while graduating high school have dreams about going to college but they just don't have the finances. So the main point to take from this post is to be grateful for everything you have everyday; because Leroy Sutton and Dartanyon Crockett are more than grateful for what they have.
Link: http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/otl/news/story?id=4371874
Wednesday, September 30, 2009
Women in men's sports
After watching the video about the girl wrestler in Michigan I think that girls should be allowed toplay men's sports no matter contact or not. People may have concerns about most boys being bigger, stronger and faster than girls. In the video, however, it stated that although the girl's opponent may have been faster than her, she was in fact stronger than he was. Also, in wrestling, your opponents are in your weight class and thus basically the same size as you are. So really she was at no disadvantage in this match or any of the matches she competed in all season. She ended up being one of the best wrestlers in the state, why take that away from her? Why take that opportunity away from any girl? Especially in a physical contact sport that is a very individual effort. There aren't many girls sports like that.
As for girls competing in other contact sports I think that as long as they are benefitting and contributing to the team they should be allowed to play. If a girl on the team helps the team win games then why would you not want her on the team? A line has to be drawn though if the girl gets injured or she is a distraction to the team. Otherwise, girls should be allowed to at least try out for any sport they would like.
As for girls competing in other contact sports I think that as long as they are benefitting and contributing to the team they should be allowed to play. If a girl on the team helps the team win games then why would you not want her on the team? A line has to be drawn though if the girl gets injured or she is a distraction to the team. Otherwise, girls should be allowed to at least try out for any sport they would like.
Monday, September 21, 2009
Jordan, Federer and Serena
I thought this conversation was very interesting. A lot of good and different points were made. The fact is, as an elite athlete you are a role model for so many people around the world and need to act like it. Yes the competition can get to them but they have to get past it and let it go. Move on and concentrate on what they do best. Frustration will not help them anyways. This happens all too often. But maybe this is what makes them elite athletes, they have that nature in them. We even see these kind of reactions from Tiger Woods, and nobody can be at fault but himself and sometimes he still looses his calm. But there is a difference between what Federer and Serena did compared to how Jordan acted.
I don't see anything really wrong with his acceptance speech. Yea he made some remarks that were borderline wrong. But he can finally get what he wanted to really say out. Things he hadn't been able to say before. And this was his night to do that. All eyes on him and his chance to say what he wants to say. I think the borderline things he said were also with good intentions and he meant good by them. He wouldn't mention the names he did unless he respected them and appreciated how they helped him along his career. His playing career in the NBA is over. He isn't going to make enemies now in the league. Let him say what he wants to say. No matter what, people respect him, look up to him and appreciate what he has done for the game all the same.
I don't see anything really wrong with his acceptance speech. Yea he made some remarks that were borderline wrong. But he can finally get what he wanted to really say out. Things he hadn't been able to say before. And this was his night to do that. All eyes on him and his chance to say what he wants to say. I think the borderline things he said were also with good intentions and he meant good by them. He wouldn't mention the names he did unless he respected them and appreciated how they helped him along his career. His playing career in the NBA is over. He isn't going to make enemies now in the league. Let him say what he wants to say. No matter what, people respect him, look up to him and appreciate what he has done for the game all the same.
Caster Semenya
I think the case of Caster Semenya is very intriguing. My view on it is that why can't there be an athlete like her and not have it be questioned like it is. Let her enjoy her accomplishments and we should praise her like any other spectacular athlete. If the Olympic Committee or anybody else is going to test her then everybody should be tested. It just isn't fair. It's as if people believe that it is impossible to be a woman and be that fast. Well, nothing is impossible. Chances are that Semenya is definitely a woman. Nobody stops and asks how they think this makes her feel with everybody sale that she is a male. She doesn't even get any time to enjoy her accomplishments and as of now her records tend to be overshadowed by the fact that she could be a male. Let her enjoy her glory. Test everybody and if it comes back that she is in fact a male then I will eat my words. But let the young incredible talent of a woman enjoy what she has accomplished.
I think this is a problem not only with great women athletes. People say it is impossible for Usain Bolt to be as fast as he is and no matter what he does there is always the question of if he takes steroids. People will say a man that is 6'6" can't possible run that fast without some enhancer. Well, its true. People need to learn that athletes are getting bigger and stronger and faster than ever with advances in equipment and training. Let things be. Don't do anything any differently than normal but if any athletes happen to be found out of either being a different sex or use performance enhancers, then deal with it then. For now let us enjoy it.
I think this is a problem not only with great women athletes. People say it is impossible for Usain Bolt to be as fast as he is and no matter what he does there is always the question of if he takes steroids. People will say a man that is 6'6" can't possible run that fast without some enhancer. Well, its true. People need to learn that athletes are getting bigger and stronger and faster than ever with advances in equipment and training. Let things be. Don't do anything any differently than normal but if any athletes happen to be found out of either being a different sex or use performance enhancers, then deal with it then. For now let us enjoy it.
Thursday, September 10, 2009
Introduction
My name is Andrew Karr and I am in my fourth year as a Sport Management major with a specialization in marketing. I am from Parma Heights, Ohio outside of Cleveland. I am taking this course as a requirement but also because I have had Dr. Spencer before and enjoy the debate in her classes. All my life I have been a fan of and participated in sports and still do both today. I am a huge Cleveland sports fan and Ohio State Buckeyes fan even though I go to BG. The subject of sport and ender is rather new to me. We talked about it a little bit in history and philosophy of sport but I am eager to dig a little deeper into the subject.
The male athletes I said I would like to see would be Shaq and Kelly Pavlik. Shaq is a player that has always intrigued me and I love his personality and that he just likes to have fun. Now that he is in Cleveland I think it may be an even bigger incentive to go see him and the rest of the 2010 NBA Champions (wishful thinking). As for Kelly Pavlik, I think boxing is a dying sport. It is pretty sad to see where boxing is compared to where is has been as one of the biggest sports in the country. Kelly is also from my home state of Ohio and has shared the success of other Youngstown raised boxers. I really want to see him fight one day and hope that he continues to dominate.
The female athlete I mentioned in class was Natalie Gulbis. I chose her for obvious reasons. She is very attractive and a very good golfer. To be quite honest there aren't many female athletes that I would be very intrigued to see. Hopefully this class will change my opinion.
As for my own history playing and watching sports I started when I was five with soccer. I never really got into soccer and stopped playing at age 8. At the age of six I got into tee-ball. I gradually moved my way up and kept with it. I played many years of travel baseball and started four years on my high school’s varsity baseball team where I hold two school records. To this day I still play in an adult wood bat league in the summer. I realized while growing up my passion was for football. I never played organized until I was in 7th grade but I started playing pick-up games around six years old. I went on to be very successful playing football in high school being named 1st team all conference and all district three times as well as honorable mention for the all-state team three times setting my schools’ rushing record. I decided to play football after high school but because of my small size was not given any scholarship offers. I played for a year at a small division III school called Baldwin-Wallace. After a year I realized college football wasn’t for me though I still had a lot of passion for the game. I still like to stay active and play other sports like basketball and golf, but nothing ever compared to playing football.
My expectations for this class and what I will learn are high. I am not very enlightened on this subject and hope to come away from this class as rather knowledgeable about the subject. I just hope the debate and conversation keeps up with the class. It makes class more enjoyable and I learn more from other students opinions.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)